
Home · Work · E-commerce
A first executive hiring system, and a COO in post, for an electronics retailer
A pre-owned electronics retailer had never hired a senior executive. Armstrat built its hiring system and advised a COO over a CEO. The first hire failed; the second, on the same framework, remains in post.
- Client
- A pre-owned consumer electronics retailer selling online and on marketplaces, run by its founder with no executive layer
- Engagement
- Design and delivery of the executive search after the transformation strategy, recommending a COO over a CEO
- Result
- A reusable senior hiring framework, since applied to other senior hires. The second appointment remains in post
- How we worked
- Embedded in the search: direct sourcing, two Armstrat-led interview rounds, a case assessment and a seat on the final panel
Published . Client name withheld.
The situation
After the transformation strategy was delivered, the founder of a pre-owned consumer electronics retailer selling online and on marketplaces planned to step back from daily leadership into a governance role and appoint professional management to run the business. Armstrat was asked to design and run the executive search.
The business had never made a hire like this. The founder held effectively all meaningful decision rights, no executive layer sat between the founder and functional managers, and there was no senior hiring process to start from. Armstrat recommended a COO rather than a CEO, because the business was not yet systemized enough to absorb a CEO-level hire, and advised making the appointment after the accountability and operating model work, not before it.
What made it hard
- The founder held effectively all meaningful decision rights, a single point of dependency across every function, with no executive layer between the founder and functional managers.
- There was no senior hiring process: no structured role specification, interview stages, assessment method or scoring criteria, and no internal benchmark for what senior capability costs or delivers.
- The role needed an uncommon profile: senior enough to command the organization, yet willing to build systems rather than run ones already in place. At the approved pay band, competitive for the local market, that pool was thin.
- Timing was contested. Armstrat’s position was that the appointment should follow the operating model and accountability work; the client’s position was that it should come first.
- The panel included the internal HR manager, who would report to the new COO, against Armstrat’s advice on independence. Final selection sat with the founder and weighed rapport and cost alongside assessed capability.

How we worked
Armstrat ran the search from inside the business rather than handing over a list of names. Our team sourced the candidates, led the assessment rounds and sat on the final panel. The work was anchored to the founder’s goal, professional management running the business, not to the number of interviews held.
- 01
Say not yet to a CEO
The business was not yet systemized enough to absorb a CEO-level hire, who would typically expect to inherit working systems. We recommended a COO who could build them, and advised appointing only after the accountability and operating model work was in place.
- 02
Build the hiring system from scratch
We built a complete executive hiring process from a standing start: role scope and job description, candidate criteria, a multi-stage interview design, question banks, a case-based assessment, panel composition and evaluation scoring.
- 03
Source directly and assess in stages
We sourced about 20 candidates directly instead of relying on agencies or inbound applications. Fifteen progressed to interview and five declined. Two Armstrat-led rounds and a case assessment produced four shortlisted candidates, and three reached a final panel with the founder and board.
- 04
Recommend on evidence at the panel
Two of three finalists were Armstrat’s picks: one with consumer goods and consulting experience plus a startup systemization role, one with P&L leadership of a refurbished phone business close to the retailer’s model. The founder chose the internally recommended candidate, at a third of the approved pay band.
- 05
Hold the standard through a reset
The first appointment was exited after about seven months, and transformation delivery slowed while it lasted. A second search followed on the same framework, and the replacement remains in post. The framework has since been applied to other senior hires.
The results
Measured against the outcomes agreed at the start.
- A reusable executive hiring capability: role specification, staged interview design, case-based assessment and evaluation criteria, since applied to other senior hires.
- A founder-led hiring instinct replaced by a structured, evidenced process with a documented funnel: about 20 sourced, 15 interviewed, 4 shortlisted and 3 to the final panel.
- The first appointment did not meet expectations and was exited after about seven months, a period in which transformation delivery slowed.
- The second appointment, run through the same framework, succeeded and remains in post.
- The business developed a working standard for senior hiring: verified track record over presentation, and structural fit over headline cost.
What leaders can take from it
Match the appointment to the organization’s maturity and sequence it after the accountability structure it will run. An executive placed in an unstructured business spends their tenure negotiating authority rather than exercising it.
Executive pay gaps are rarely the real cost. A hire at a third of the market rate who slows a transformation program is the more expensive option.
Keep the hiring panel independent and verify track records directly. A direct report choosing their own manager creates a conflict no process fixes, and a gap explained by a venture should be checked against that venture’s actual dates.
Questions about this work
Should a founder-led business hire a COO or a CEO first?
Usually a COO, while the business still runs on the founder. A CEO-level candidate typically expects to inherit working systems, while a COO can be hired to build them. Armstrat recommended a COO for this retailer because it was not yet systemized enough to absorb a CEO, and advised appointing after the accountability and operating model work, not before.
What if the first executive hire does not work out?
Keep the framework and raise the standard it applies. Here the first appointee was exited after about seven months, and transformation delivery slowed in that time. Armstrat’s framework was reused for a second search, and the replacement remains in post. The business came away with a working standard for senior hires: verified track record over presentation, and structural fit over headline cost.
More work
18%reduction in freight costFreight cost down 18% for a $120M multi-channel retailer
22custom ERP modules delivered in 37 weeks against a 44-week planA custom ERP, 22 modules, 7 weeks ahead of plan
10%Approximate net margin at FY2024 close, up from loss-making monthsOnline retailer from losses to about 10% net margin

Bring us the hard problem.
We agree the outcomes first, then work inside your business until they hold.